The Seductress 2

I didn’t tell anyone what happened between Carly and I. Besides, who was I going to tell? If anyone found out, it would seriously tarnish my reputation.

I’d certainly enjoyed what we’d done underwater. But I also felt guilty. Perhaps it was because of the church’s message. Or maybe it was because we weren’t officially boyfriend and girlfriend yet.

I tried to rationalize it by convincing myself Carly had been the aggressor. But I knew I could have put a stop to it at any time. Now I was starting to develop feelings for her.

I got a call from her the next day. She wanted to go back out to the lake and swim with me again. She wanted to know what day would be good for me.

Everything seemed to be happening so fast. A part of me thought I should turn her down. But I’d enjoyed our time underwater, and I didn’t want to stop.

I asked if Thursday afternoon would work. I hoped there wouldn’t be too many people out at the lake to spy on us during a workday. I figured Thursday would work much better than a Friday or the weekend.

She told me Thursday afternoon would be great. She would use her parent’s car so I wouldn’t have to come pick her up. She would also pack some sandwiches if I could bring something to drink.

I got to the lake on Thursday a little after noon. A part of me couldn’t help questioning what I thought I was doing. But I’d already become too deeply entangled.

Carly showed up in her parents’ car wearing a nice sundress. It quickly came off to reveal a skimpy black bikini. That didn’t help my stiffening cock in the slightest.

We ate her sandwiches and drank the sodas I’d brought along. But we made sure it wasn’t a heavy lunch. Then we got into the water.

The raft was clear across the inlet, the wind having blown it there from the night before. Carly and I swam over to fetch it. We brought it back and parked it right in the middle over the deepest part of the inlet.

There were other people out on the lake. But for the most part, we were just out of sight. I didn’t want anyone else knowing about Carly and I until I could fully process what was going on between us.

After reaching the middle of the inlet, Carly blatantly stripped out of her bikini, tossing the pieces up onto the raft. She smiled as she told me, “I hope you don’t mind. Last time we weren’t naked for very long. This time I want to swim in the nude. Is that ok with you?”

She gave me a questioning look. Right away I knew what she wanted from me. So I let my little head do all the thinking.

I gamely pulled my trunks off, eager to please. Then I tossed them up onto the raft. “That’s great!” she gasped with a huge grin. “This way I get to see for myself just how turned on you become. Now I want to see if I can swim down to the bottom on my own while you’re swimming beside me.”

We both filled our lungs before submerging. We swam down until I actually touched the muddy bottom. It was so murky that I could hardly see Carly until she found me and grabbed on.

She pulled me to her and started kissing me deeply. Our naked bodies pressed up against each other. Her hands were all over me.

I felt her grab my dick and start to stroke it. I grunted bubbles into her mouth as our tongues intertwined. It felt so good that I didn’t think to stop her. Besides, I really didn’t want to.

We finally shot up to the surface for another breath. We clung to the raft until she filled her lungs and submerged. That’s when I felt her lips wrap around my quivering shaft.

She eagerly bobbed up and down on it, losing bubbles out of her nose. Then she popped up for a breath. “Your turn to do oral on me,” she panted.

I may have been clueless around the girls at school. But from all my “research” I certainly knew enough to know what was expected of me. At least I thought I did.

I submerged and caressed her mounds. Then I latched onto a nipple with my mouth. I sucked on it, using my tongue to flick it a little.

She joined me underwater, moaning up bubbles as she jerked my meat. I licked and sucked on her breasts. Then we surfaced to get another breath.

She was eager to submerge again. This time she forced my head between her legs. Right away I knew what she wanted.

I hesitated only a moment before exploring with my tongue. I found her nub and nibbled on it with my lips, making it swell. She squirmed against me as she groaned and bubbled.

I licked between her labia until she was wriggling and trembling. It was a real turn-on making her squirm underwater. I heard her lose bubbles as she moaned really loud.

We surfaced again to catch our breaths. She panted as she looked me right in the eye. Then she dubiously asked, “Are you sure you haven’t done any of this before?”

I told her I’d done a lot of research on the subject. But I didn’t give any specific details. I didn’t want her to know I was more worldly than I wanted to let on.

She grinned as she replied, “Porn research?” She laughed as my face went red. She told me it was no big deal.

She filled her lungs and submerged again. Once more her lips wrapped around my dick. I slipped under and reached down to grope and fondle her boobs as she vacuumed my cock, her cheeks going concave.

After a while we came back up for another breath. She panted as she told me, “Now I want to 69 at the bottom of the lake. You know what that is, don’t you?”

I blushed as I told her yes. She said she wanted to suck my cock while I licked her twat. But she didn’t want to waste any time fumbling around to find me.

I told her to grab on. She wrapped her arms around my neck as we both inhaled deeply. Then I took us down toward the bottom of the lake.

It got darker and colder the deeper we went, helping my cock stiffen even more. Then my hands touched the muddy bottom. Carly shifted her position on top of me, feeling around until she was able to wrap her lips around my dick.

Even though my sinuses stung, I shifted my body underneath her until my face went between her legs. I licked through the folds of her labia as I nibbled on her nub. She really groaned up bubbles as she gobbled me down.

We stayed down for as long as we could. It felt absolutely incredible; two warm, naked bodies pressed together at the bottom of a murky lake. I loved the way she was responding to my probing tongue and nibbling lips.

She finally broke away and shot up toward the surface. My lungs were hurting as I followed her up. For a moment I wondered if we’d stayed down too long.

We burst up panting loudly for breath. She gasped, “Damn, that was hot! How deep were we?” I told her I didn’t really know. But it had to have been at least a good eighteen feet… maybe even deeper.

She kissed me deeply, her hand grabbing my dick again. We submerged near the raft as my hand found her crotch. This time I wriggled a couple fingers into her slit.

She moaned and bubbled as she writhed against me. It was incredibly erotic. Never in my wildest dreams did I ever expect to meet a woman with the same aquatic desires as I.

We surfaced to catch our breath. Once more, she pushed me under onto my back. We were near the surface when she gobbled my cock as my face found her crotch.

We were just below the surface, feasting in another 69 position. By now there were very few self-conscious thoughts on my part. I was horny as hell, and was really enjoying our time in the water.

We surfaced again to catch our breath. She eagerly stroked my erection. Then she told me, “Now I want to go deep and kiss you again.”

We inhaled deeply before submerging. She followed me down, keeping a hand on my ankle so she wouldn’t lose me. I stretched my hand out, but this time I didn’t find the bottom.

Carly pulled me to her and kissed me hard. Once more, her tongue deeply probed my oral cavity. I felt her hand stroke my cock the entire time.

At some point I felt her move my dick around. A moment later I felt myself slide deep inside something warm and velvety. That’s when something clenched wonderfully around my shaft.

Carly eagerly began to ride me, grunting and bubbling like crazy. She kissed me so hard I thought she was going to suck my tonsils out. That’s when it occurred to me what had just happened.

I had never planned on things going this far. But it was far too late to stop now. Besides, it felt too damned good for me to want to pull out.

She eagerly rode me, grunting into my mouth as our tongues intertwined. I could not resist, nor could I make myself stop. A moment later I felt it swell within me.

I tried to grunt a warning as I started to push her away. Carly just wrapped her legs around me even more. She held on tight, gripping me like an octopus until there was no way I could pry her off me.

My cock suddenly went off inside her. I could not stop spurting as I pumped load after load deep inside her. It felt absolutely incredible, especially as we drifted near the bottom of the lake.

I tried to pull out as I was running out of breath and needed to surface. She kept her legs wrapped around me as she continued to kiss me. I finally used my arms and legs to work us back toward the surface.

We finally popped up gasping loudly for breath. She gasped, “That was so fucking awesome!” Then she proceeded to kiss me so hard that she sucked the tonsils out of my throat.

I could tell I was still inside her. I’d softened, but I hadn’t yet slipped out. It was as though she didn’t want me too.

She finally squeezed me out of her. I felt my conscience nudge me, and I mumbled something about heading back to shore to take a break. But she was having none of it.

“That was fucking incredible! I want to go again!” And with that she submerged to wrap her lips back around my dick.

I made a halfhearted attempt to stop her. But I didn’t really want to. In no time at all I found myself stiffening right back up.

She came up out of the water and gasped for breath. Then she pushed me down between her legs. I dutifully began lapping up her pussy, noticing a distinct change in flavor.

She stiffened and cried out as she held my head in place. She slipped under, moaning and bubbling. Then she let out a bubbly cry as she shuddered hard, squeezing her legs until I thought she was going to crack my head open like an egg.

She let me go, and the two of us surfaced. She blurted out, “I just had a fucking orgasm! I want to go again!” And with that she shoved me right back down between her legs.

Once more I licked between the folds of her labia as bubbles dribbled out of my mouth. I pushed my tongue into her slit as I grabbed her ass. Then I used a couple fingers to thrust in and out of her clenching slit.

She stiffened and bubbled. Then she cried out as she shuddered against me. We both popped back up to catch our breaths.

After a couple of minutes she gasped, “I want to get you back to bottom of the lake again!”

I looked at her, suddenly feeling a little uncomfortable. I had a good idea what she wanted to have happen again. This time I became a little hesitant, hemming and hawing about it.

My erection didn’t make things any easier, especially when she grabbed it and stroked me. She told me, “I know you’re trying to be careful. But would you just relax already? There’s no danger. Mom’s got me on the pill, so we’re good to go.”

Right then, something told me I wasn’t the only one she’d been sexually active with. But my erection didn’t really give a damn. That’s when she climbed into my lap, impaling herself on my throbbing erection.

“All the way down!” she demanded. “I want to fuck you at the bottom of the lake! I hope that’s ok. You’re the only one I’ve ever fu – I mean… you’re the only one I’ve ever been to the bottom of the lake with.”

Her words confirmed I wasn’t the only one she’d fucked. But a hard cock knows no conscience. That’s when she gasped, “Take us all the way down! I’ll hang on!”

We both inhaled deeply. Then we sort of jackknifed downward. I pulled hard with my arms, kicking with my legs to get us down.

Carly stayed wrapped around me like an octopus. She clung on tightly with her legs while riding me down as she bounced on my erection. I could actually feel her fucking me.

I kept swimming down, shamefully enjoying the way it felt being inside her. To my surprise, I actually touched the bottom. In fact, I almost drove Carly into the mud.

She ended up flat on her back, French-kissing me like a maniac. Her tongue probed deeply inside my oral cavity as she rode me. I thrust in and out of her while keeping her pinned to the bottom.

She grunted and bubbled into my mouth. It felt absolutely incredible. I couldn’t believe I was actually going to cum again!

I tried to give her a warning. She just wrapped her legs tighter around my waist. Then she really rode me, her pussy clenching like crazy as she kissed me hard.

I grunted as I thrust deep into her warm, throbbing womanhood. A moment later I pumped a second load deep inside her. She moaned up bubbles until she went into little spasms.

She suddenly grunted as she pushed me off. She shot up for the surface, with me a split-second behind. We both burst up panting like crazy.

“Awesome!” she finally gasped. “That was so fucking awesome! I’ve never done it at the bottom of the lake before!”

She saw the look in my eyes. Then she tried to correct herself. “I mean… I never thought I would ever have sex with anyone like that, certainly not at the bottom of a lake!”

I thought about saying something. But I decided not to push it. My little head didn’t seem to care I wasn’t the first who’d plowed her garden.

We climbed onto the raft and stretched out on our backs. We lay like that for a few minutes, sunning ourselves. I looked around to make sure nobody could see us skinny-dipping, much less lying nude on a raft.

By now we had drifted closer to shore. Carly noticed and said we needed to push it back out if we were going to do any more swimming and fucking. I was surprised at her brazenness.

She climbed on top of me and started kissing me on the raft. My cock immediately stiffened again. She felt it harden between us and began humping against it as she moaned into my mouth.

She rolled us around on top of the raft until we rolled off into the water. She just kept kissing me. By now she was getting pretty good about holding her breath with our tongues intertwined.

We surfaced to catch our breath. Then she panted, “I want to 69 again. You are so good with that tongue of yours.”

What could I say? I wanted to please her. I also liked the way her lips wrapped around my dick as she tried to suck the cream out of my balls.

We slipped underwater and moved into position. This time I was on top of her. Her mouth latched onto my dick as she locked my head in place with her thighs.

We really went at it. She kept grunting up bubbles as she sucked my cock. My tongue must have kept hitting the right spot because she humped against my face until she bubbled her breath away and had to surface again.

We came up gasping for breath. She kissed me hard before pulling away and telling me how talented I was with my tongue. Then she told me she wanted another fuck down on the bottom of the lake.

My conscience tried to tell me not to do it. But I was horny and could barely hear it. Besides, I loved the way she wanted to fuck me while holding her breath at the bottom of the lake.

I looked at her and smiled, thinking I’d cleverly found a way around it. “If you want to fuck me, you’re going to have to find me first.” Then I filled my lungs and submerged.

I could just barely make out the words, “Oh no, you don’t!” Then I pulled hard for the bottom. It was as though I was trying to escape.

I didn’t swim all that hard as I neared the bottom. It was murky, and I thought maybe I’d lost her. Then I reached the mud, the bottom not nearly so deep since we were closer to shore.

To be honest, I wanted her to find me way more than I wanted to remain virtuous. Besides, it was much too late for that. We’d already done so much in the water together.

She grabbed my ankle, causing me to bubble as my cock really stiffened. She pulled me to her before climbing into my lap. She wrapped her legs around my waist and pushed me over backwards until she was riding me in a cowgirl position.

She grunted and bubbled as she eagerly rode me near the bottom of the lake. I grasped onto her sides to hold on. She responded by grabbing my hands and pulling them to her breasts, indicating she wanted me to grab onto something else.

I groped and squeezed her tits as she eagerly rode me. We grunted and bubbled down near the bottom of the lake. I could feel us drifting upwards until I lost enough air to cause us to descend.

My stomach was starting to heave when I felt my back come in contact with the muddy bottom. She must have felt it with her legs, being as how they were wrapped tightly around me. She really rode me, grunting and bubbling up a storm.

I began to feel the strain in my lungs. I could also feel it in her heaving tits. She suddenly launched herself off and made a mad dash for the surface.

I shot up after her, concerned I might have stayed down too deep. I followed her up until we both burst up gasping loudly for breath. We swam to the raft which had drifted even closer to shore.

She panted for breath as she kissed me again. She grabbed my dick and jerked it while asking, “You still hard?”

I nodded… “Unh – hunh.”

“Good. I want to go back down. This time I want you to fuck me doggy style. You know what that is, don’t you?”

I nodded as I looked down. We were closer to the shore. The water was not so deep, meaning we should be able to reach the bottom easily enough.

“Now!” she gasped. Then we both submerged. I followed her down, staying close to her.

The bottom came up much faster this time. We were maybe 10-12 feet down. Carly immediately got on her hands and knees as I got on my knees behind her.

She grabbed me and centered me against her opening. Then she pushed back against me until I pushed deep inside her. She wasn’t taking any chances I might back out at the last second.

She began pushing back against me as I thrust into her. Once more I felt her hands come back and grab onto mine, directing where she wanted them. I ended up reaching underneath her to grope her boobs as I thrust into her from behind.

I was eager for another release. I could tell I was getting close. I knew I shouldn’t have been fucking her at all. But I just couldn’t make myself stop, especially with the two of us holding our breath at the bottom of the lake.

I groped her good and hard as I thrust into her. She grunted up more bubbles as she pushed back against me. Then I felt my balls swell until I exploded deep inside her.

She groaned up bubbles; she must have felt my cum in her. I really groped her boobs as I thrust deep and hard. I wanted to make sure she squeezed every last drop out of me.

It felt like she responded by clenching and crying out. She really milked me dry. Then she grunted up bubbles, a sound that didn’t seem right.

She started to go limp in my grasp. I pulled out of her, but she didn’t make a move toward the surface. I started to panic as I grabbed her and tried hauling her back up.

I was out of breath, my lungs empty. I couldn’t tell if she was conscious or not. For a moment I was afraid we were both going to drown. Then I got her to the surface.

For a moment she didn’t say or do anything. Then she started up a severe coughing fit. I told her over and over again how sorry I was.

I worked her over to the raft and got her on top. Then I finished kicking the raft back to shore. Somehow we both managed to get back into our swimsuits.

I asked again if she was ok. She gave me a not so happy glance as she told me, “You tried to drown me!”

“No, I didn’t! We just got carried away. You were the one who wanted to go back down, remember?”

“But you tried to drown me!”

“You wanted to fuck on the bottom of the lake!” I was surprised and a little put out by her sudden anger.

She gathered up all her stuff and headed for her parents’ car. She was clearly angry, spoiling out time together at the lake. My frantic apologies didn’t make a bit of difference as she climbed in, turned the car around and roared off.

I watched her drive away, feeling crestfallen. That certainly hadn’t ended well. The problem was: I was starting to develop feelings for her. It felt like I was actually falling in love.
—
Carly didn’t call me after that. I thought about calling her, but I didn’t want her to hang up on me. I also didn’t know how her parents would react if they found out we’d been sexual in the lake. I didn’t even know whether or not she’d told them.

Things certainly changed at church that Sunday. I started getting looks and snickers from just about everyone in the youth group. Carly was back to being snarky with me while hanging out with her friends.

The way they looked at me made me suspect they knew all about our lake adventures. There was only one person who could have told them. I felt utterly humiliated… and more than a little angry.

Our next youth group outing at the lake was not at all what I’d hoped it would be. I thought Carly would at least show some respect toward me. Instead, she made fun of me behind my back as she sat among her group of friends.

By now I was sure everybody knew. One of the guys I knew finally told me Carly had made a bet with some of the others, claiming she could take my virginity. Now she was cashing in and bragging about it.

I was mortified. But deep down, I was furious over being taken advantage of. I made it a point to spend as much time in the water by myself as possible, avoiding her and the others. I couldn’t believe Carly had turned out to be such a bitch.

A couple friends near the water quietly told me not to let it bother me. They could tell how it had affected me. But it was incredibly hard to ignore. It occurred to me I was going to have to live with this for a while, or at least until I moved away or something.

There was a lot of laughter and pointing at me. Some of the others became indecisive, having a hard time deciding just who to side with. They would be in the firing line if they chose to publicly side with me. So I was pretty much abandoned and ignored for the duration.

Mrs. Walker finally got pissed off about the whole thing. She told her daughter to take the car and all her disgusting friends and drive home. She also told her she was grounded.

Our time at the lake as a church group had officially come to an end. I started to get out of the water. But Mrs. Walker came down to the shoreline and held up a hand.

“Not you, Robert. You don’t have to go anywhere. You can stay as long as you like.”

She turned to see her daughter climbing into the car. The group was breaking up and heading for their vehicles. That left me all alone in the water.

Mrs. Walker was wearing a yellow one-piece. But it was cut well up the thighs, and it revealed a lot of cleavage. The way her breasts pushed through the material with her nipples protruding made it difficult for me not to stare.

“I’m real sorry about that, Robert. My daughter has been bragging about what she did with you for several days now. I guess she did it as a bet. She wanted to prove the right girl in the right situation could make you lose your virginity. I’m sorry she did that to you. I’m seriously considering making her take all the cash she won and give it to you.”

I was really embarrassed. But I tried to shrug it off. I wanted to make light of it despite knowing the hell my next few weeks were going to be like.

“You don’t have to do that, Mrs. Walker. I guess she earned it fair and square. She was, uh… she was good, especially the way she seduced me while we were swimming together. I had no idea women could be like that.”

I saw a look cross her face as though she’d felt included in the generalization. I quickly tried to undo the damage I’d inflicted. “I’m sorry. I didn’t mean it that way. It’s just that I, uh… the way we, uh… the way I did your daughter, uh… I mean… I’m sorry I…” How the hell was I supposed to apologize for fucking her daughter?

“It’s ok, Robert,” she said with a dismissive wave. “I thought I raised her better than that. Don’t feel bad about fucking her. You aren’t the first, and you certainly won’t be the last.”

My face went beet red. I lowered my head. “Maybe, uh… maybe I should go home now?”

“Uh… Robert? Can I ask a favor?”

“Sure, Mrs. Walker.”

“Well, I’m a little angry with my daughter right now, and I want to cool off. But as you can see, I’m now without a ride home. Would you take me home as soon as I finish my swim? You can even come out and swim with me if you like.”

I looked at her chest and blushed. She caught me looking and smiled. “Oh, that’s all right, Robert. Don’t worry about it. I understand the type of attention I get because of the suits I wear. Young men can’t help staring. I hope you don’t mind how I look in it.”

“Oh, I don’t mind, Mrs. Walker.”

“Do you like it?” She even twirled right there on the shoreline for me.

I felt my dick harden in my trunks. “Uh… very nice, Mrs. Walker.”

“I see I’ve embarrassed you. I’m sorry. Let’s get into the water and go for a swim; shall we?”

I felt better once she waded out with me into the water. We walked further out until my bulge was submerged and not as easily observable. Then she pointed toward the end of the lake. “Can you make that swim?”

“I think so.”

“Then let’s go.”

She set out with long, smooth strokes. I set off after her until I’d caught up to her. We swam a steady freestyle together until we neared the shore in four feet of water.

She stood up and said, “Can we rest for a few minutes, Robert?” I said it was ok with me. So we waded in and sat in water that covered our laps.

“I want to apologize again for my daughter, Robert.” I just waved her off. I told her I appreciated her kindness. I would just have to accept I’d been tricked and that I would have to be more careful in the future.

“I appreciate the swim, Robert. When I come out here with the group, I don’t often get to enjoy the water all that much. Sometimes I feel I have to stay close to shore and keep an eye on my daughter. You can certainly see why after today, am I right?”

I nodded with a smile. But her sitting there with her chest sticking out in that yellow one-piece was doing me no favors.

“I don’t know what to believe when she says these things, Robert. Sometimes she tells tall tales. She said you did some breath-holding first. Did you two really hold your breath underwater for nearly two minutes? I mean, that sounds kinda iffy to me, especially if you were doing… other things underwater.”

She looked at me as I squirmed a little. She saw I was uncomfortable and tried to backtrack. “You don’t have to tell me if you don’t want to. I was just being curious is all. A couple of times she sounded proud of what she’d done, especially the breath-holding part.”

I realized Mrs. Walker was trying to be nice to me. I liked our swim and the way she was sitting so close. I decided to open up a little more, being as how I wanted to be nice to her.

“Yes, we did things underwater, Mrs. Walker.” Then I pointed across the lake toward the inlet on the opposite shore. “We did it over there out of sight while using the raft.”

“You mean that wooden raft that often floats around in the lake?”

“That’s the one.” I looked around before adding, “I don’t see it anywhere. It must be near the shore in that inlet over there.”

“I see.” Then she stood up.

“I guess I’m ready to go. Race you back?”

She got up and rushed into deeper water. I chased after her. We both swam hard back to the original shore.

I beat her by a few strokes. She laughed as we waded out together and headed for my towel. “You win,” she replied with a grin. “I guess that means I have to let you show me that inlet and the raft. I want to understand what Carly was talking about so I’ll know how long I have to ground her.”

“Oh, you don’t have to punish her, Mrs. Walker. But you do what you’ve got to do.”

“Would it be all right if you showed me that inlet?”

“Sure, Mrs. Walker.”

I gave her my towel as I noticed her daughter hadn’t left one behind. Then we headed up to my car. A part of me felt funny spending all this time with her. But another part felt like she was only trying to make up for the humiliation I’d endured earlier.

2021 (written May 23 ’21 by riwa)